Quick Dry Top Coat Showdown: Dreamland Lacquer, KBShimmer, Paint Box Polish, Top Shelf Lacquer

Purchased by Me buttonHi everyone! I’ve been having troubles lately with quick dry top coats just not working out – Digital Nails Ain’t Nobody Got Time for That was my main squeeze, which stopped working; then Darling Diva Polish PETC became my love and it stopped working for me. I thought I’d do a little QDTC challenge between 4 brands: Dreamland Lacquer, KBShimmer, Paint Box Polish, and Top Shelf Lacquer. I’ll show you the results after 5 days of wear in just a moment but let’s talk about ship times, then application, then wear time.

Keep in mind that every person’s body chemistry is different, and your mileage may vary – this is only a reporting of how these top coats worked with me.

Ship Times
Dreamland: Ordered on a Saturday, received the following Saturday
KBShimmer: Ordered on a Sunday, received on Thursday
Paint Box Polish: Ordered on a Saturday, received on Thursday; my order also included a mani bomb, which was a nice touch
Top Shelf Lacquer: (Older order but I’m sure I received my order within 3 days of purchase.)

Application
I used each top coat over a layered manicure: 2 coats of China Glaze Midtown Magic, 1 layer of Baroness X Opulent Oddity, 1 layer of Baroness X Dulcinea.

Baroness X Dulcinea, Baroness X Opulent Oddity, China Glaze Midtown Magic | Be Happy And Buy Polish

1 minute test
Dreamland: No fingerprint left
KBShimmer: Fingerprint left
Paint Box Polish: Fingerprint left
Top Shelf Lacquer: Fingerprint left

5 minute test
Dreamland: Bumpable
KBShimmer: No fingerprint left, bumpable
Paint Box Polish: No fingerprint left, bumpable
Top Shelf Lacquer: Faint fingerprint left, bumpable

10 minute test
Dreamland: Bumpable
KBShimmer: Bumpable
Paint Box Polish: Not as bumpable
Top Shelf Lacquer: Bumpable

20 minute test
Dreamland: Not as bumpable
KBShimmer: Not as bumpable
Paint Box Polish: Same as 10 minute
Top Shelf Lacquer: Same as 10 minute

60 minute test
Dreamland: Still dent-able but would feel comfortable getting ready for the day
KBShimmer: Still dent-able but better than the Dreamland
Paint Box Polish: Still dent-able
Top Shelf Lacquer: Still fairly bumpable, would not feel comfortable getting ready for the day

5 day wear
At the end of 5 days (which is pretty much my limit for a mani!), I took a picture of each nail. My left hand index finger (Dreamland) chipped first in the 5 days, I think because there was glitter right at the edge that lifted. My right hand middle finger (KBShimmer) chipped the next day. At the end of 5 days, each finger had tip wear but there were no additional chips.

Dreamland:

Dreamland Lacquer Ooh Shiny left hand | Be Happy And Buy Polish

Dreamland Lacquer Ooh Shiny right hand | Be Happy And Buy Polish

KBShimmer:

KBShimmer Clearly On Top left hand | Be Happy And Buy Polish

KBShimmer Clearly On Top right hand | Be Happy And Buy Polish

Paint Box Polish:

Paint Box Polish Like Lightning left hand | Be Happy And Buy Polish

Paint Box Polish Like Lightning right hand | Be Happy And Buy Polish

Top Shelf Lacquer:

Top Shelf Lacquer quick dry top coat left hand | Be Happy And Buy Polish

Top Shelf Lacquer quick dry top coat right hand | Be Happy And Buy Polish

In terms of which top coat actually performed under the category of “quick dry” best, I’d have to give that to Dreamland; worst was Top Shelf Lacquer. In terms of which top coat had the best shine & not as much tip wear at the end of 5 days, I’d give that to Top Shelf Lacquer.

The differences though between how each top coat performed was so minimal that I think a customer purchasing any of these would be happy.

If you’ve had any experiences with these top coats, I’d love for you to comment with your experience!

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Quick Dry Top Coat Showdown: Dreamland Lacquer, KBShimmer, Paint Box Polish, Top Shelf Lacquer

  1. Haven’t used any of those, but I have used/tested quite a few. As of what I have noticed my index finger and middle finger seem to get more tip wear than any other finger, it doesn’t matter which top coat I use, tip wear pattern is always the same. I think it’s cause we use those fingers more than any other, hence it might actually not be from glitter being at the edge of the nail.

  2. Pingback: Layered Manicure with China Glaze Midtown Magic, Baroness X Opulent Oddity, Baroness X Dulcinea | Be Happy and Buy Polish

Thanks for commenting, I love hearing from you!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.